Re: 94 Accord and fuel pump relay symptoms...sorta, see post
You are accessing this site in a read-only mode. For full access to all member benefits, including message posting, please login or register. Registration is completely free, simple, and takes only a few seconds.
Login |
Free CarKB.com registration |
Whole discussion thread
The message you are replying to and its parents are listed in the reverse order with the most recent posts first. This might not be the whole discussion thread. To read all the messages in this thread please click here.
Re: 94 Accord and fuel pump relay symptoms...sorta, see post
| Tegger | 10 Feb 2008 23:26 |
> : All I can suggest right now is to monitor the two-second continuity > : at the Main Relay plug using an analog VOM. You should also get > : continuity at that terminal when you crank the starter. > > see above for # of pins It looks like I'm going to have to update my diagrams.
Although all the Honda manual /diagrams/ are the same, the pin assignments shown on the Accord ones are slightly different from the Civic ones.
What I refer to as Terminal 8 is actually Terminal ONE on your car.
(And seven pins is all you'll ever find connected on any Main Relay.)
> : You may also want to chek all the voltage feeds from the ignition > : switch to make sure the ignition switch is actually carrying steady [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > It comes on right away, and it goes off two seconds after the fuel > pump starts when the pump starts. That's totally screwy.
> The delay between the check engine > light coming on and the fuel pump start is anywhere from a fraction of > a second to 4-5 minutes. Right now it's back to a fraction of a > second. About an hour ago it was 5 seconds before the fuel pump ran.
> : Any codes stored in the ECU? Have you checked? > > No codes. Yes I did check (with the jumper in, MIL stays solid on > after the fuel pump 2 second cycle runs) Two questions: 1) Have you pulled the carpet back to see if the ECM cover has any sort of corrosion on it? 2) Do you have any unexplained water leaks onto the front passenger carpet?
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
|
| Howard Goldstein | 10 Feb 2008 19:12 |
: hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1202662858.33747@news.queue.to: : : > On Sun, 10 Feb 2008 10:44:59 +0000 (UTC), Tegger <tegger@tegger.c0m> : > wrote: : : > : : > : : > : Disconnect the Main Relay's plug from the Main Relay. Connect a : > : multimeter (set to Ohms) between the plug's Terminal 8 and a body : > : ground. : > : : > : Turn the key to "II". At thre same time as you turn the key, watch : > : the multimeter carefully. Do you get continuity for two seconds? : > : > I will check this when I can reproduce it hopefully later today, : > ambient is still a little too cool to reproduce long enough to test; : > there's discernable (maybe a 1/4 second?) delay between going to II : > and the fuel pump starting, and my DVM doesn't react that quickly. : > Normally IIRC there's no delay at all. : : : : Use an analog VOM. It's a lot easier to see a needle move than a display : flicker.
I wish I still had one :( I'll have to pick a cheap one up somewhere. BTW it's a 7 pin plug on the main relay :(
: : : : > : > : : > : Have you checked the ECU ground at the thermostat housing? Have you : > : checked the engine grounds at the transmission housing and from : > : valve cover to shock tower? : > : > Your memory is good: I tried to find a ground point near both radiator : > hoses and for the life of me could not, : : : : My memory ain't that good. : : The ECU ground is often under/at the thermostat housing. Looks like in your : case G101 is actually at the firewall. :
(it's close to it - the intake manifold is about 6" ahead of the firewall and there's a nice bolt with a pair of wires going to it)
: : : : > nor do I see one at the : > transmission housing (standard transmission) Is it an undocumented : > ground? : : : : It's one of the battery cables, shown on pg 23-14 of the manual. :
OK that one's solid
: : : The electrical system .pdf at this page : > http://www.dhost.info/accordinfo/ with the grounds at .pdf page 15 : > looks like it's right out of my service manual. I have G101 very : > tight after crimping down harder on the two leads attached to it (G101 : > being on the intake manifold; p51 of the .pdf) : > : > I've re-secured all of the documented grounds in the engine : > compartment and the one back by the fuel pump connector. I haven't : > checked grounds under the center console which has been off a couple : > of times for radio installs. I ohmed the two grounds at the ECM A23 : > and A24 connector to the vehicle body at the passenger kick : > panel. : > : > It seems like the only thing I haven't checked are the connections : > through the injector resistors and IAC (p. 14 in the fuelemiss.pdf at : > that link, p. 12 in the Honda service manual) : > : > The valve cover<>shock tower<>body ground is good. : > : > : : : All I can suggest right now is to monitor the two-second continuity at the : Main Relay plug using an analog VOM. You should also get continuity at that : terminal when you crank the starter.
see above for # of pins
: : You may also want to chek all the voltage feeds from the ignition switch to : make sure the ignition switch is actually carrying steady current at all : its usual "key-on" live locations.
I'll do that right now
: : Does the Check Engine light illuminate during the first two-seconds of key- : on, then go off again right away?
It comes on right away, and it goes off two seconds after the fuel pump starts when the pump starts. The delay between the check engine light coming on and the fuel pump start is anywhere from a fraction of a second to 4-5 minutes. Right now it's back to a fraction of a second. About an hour ago it was 5 seconds before the fuel pump ran.
: Any codes stored in the ECU? Have you checked?
No codes. Yes I did check (with the jumper in, MIL stays solid on after the fuel pump 2 second cycle runs)
|
| Tegger | 10 Feb 2008 18:12 |
> : Disconnect the Main Relay's plug from the Main Relay. Connect a > : multimeter (set to Ohms) between the plug's Terminal 8 and a body [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > and the fuel pump starting, and my DVM doesn't react that quickly. > Normally IIRC there's no delay at all. Use an analog VOM. It's a lot easier to see a needle move than a display flicker.
> : Have you checked the ECU ground at the thermostat housing? Have you > : checked the engine grounds at the transmission housing and from > : valve cover to shock tower? > > Your memory is good: I tried to find a ground point near both radiator > hoses and for the life of me could not, My memory ain't that good.
The ECU ground is often under/at the thermostat housing. Looks like in your case G101 is actually at the firewall.
> nor do I see one at the > transmission housing (standard transmission) Is it an undocumented > ground? It's one of the battery cables, shown on pg 23-14 of the manual.
The electrical system .pdf at this page
> http://www.dhost.info/accordinfo/ with the grounds at .pdf page 15 > looks like it's right out of my service manual. I have G101 very [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > > The valve cover<>shock tower<>body ground is good. All I can suggest right now is to monitor the two-second continuity at the Main Relay plug using an analog VOM. You should also get continuity at that terminal when you crank the starter.
You may also want to chek all the voltage feeds from the ignition switch to make sure the ignition switch is actually carrying steady current at all its usual "key-on" live locations.
Does the Check Engine light illuminate during the first two-seconds of key- on, then go off again right away?
Any codes stored in the ECU? Have you checked?
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
|
| Howard Goldstein | 10 Feb 2008 17:00 |
: hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1202582202.68680@news.queue.to: : : > On Sat, 09 Feb 2008 11:29:54 -0700, motsco_ <motsco_@interbaun.com> : > wrote: : > : Howard Goldstein wrote: : > : > Anyone ever repair a funky ECM by opening it up and cleaning up : > : > any bad solder joints? Will the ECM avoid sending fuel if it sees : > : > something "wrong" at its sensors although there aren't any codes : > : > stored? Should I toss the ECM at this point? : > : > : > : > Long nauseating details and plea follow: : > : > : > : : > : -------------------- : > : : > : If you sit there with key in position II and nothing happens (no : > : fuel pump), smack the dash on the left side. If the fuel pump goes : > : GzzzzzzCLICK, the car will now start. They NEVER fail while the : > : engine is running because the vibration makes the bad solder : > : connection work enough. : > : Resolder or replace the relay. : > : > Hi, we chatted about this a few months ago. Neither resolder nor : > replace makes no difference. Sitting there with the key on II for a : > few minutes and it starts working. The ECM isn't pulling the second : > relay down :( : > : : : : Disconnect the Main Relay's plug from the Main Relay. Connect a multimeter : (set to Ohms) between the plug's Terminal 8 and a body ground. : : Turn the key to "II". At thre same time as you turn the key, watch the : multimeter carefully. Do you get continuity for two seconds?
I will check this when I can reproduce it hopefully later today, ambient is still a little too cool to reproduce long enough to test; there's discernable (maybe a 1/4 second?) delay between going to II and the fuel pump starting, and my DVM doesn't react that quickly. Normally IIRC there's no delay at all.
: : Have you checked the ECU ground at the thermostat housing? Have you checked : the engine grounds at the transmission housing and from valve cover to : shock tower?
Your memory is good: I tried to find a ground point near both radiator hoses and for the life of me could not, nor do I see one at the transmission housing (standard transmission) Is it an undocumented ground? The electrical system .pdf at this page http://www.dhost.info/accordinfo/ with the grounds at .pdf page 15 looks like it's right out of my service manual. I have G101 very tight after crimping down harder on the two leads attached to it (G101 being on the intake manifold; p51 of the .pdf)
I've re-secured all of the documented grounds in the engine compartment and the one back by the fuel pump connector. I haven't checked grounds under the center console which has been off a couple of times for radio installs. I ohmed the two grounds at the ECM A23 and A24 connector to the vehicle body at the passenger kick panel.
It seems like the only thing I haven't checked are the connections through the injector resistors and IAC (p. 14 in the fuelemiss.pdf at that link, p. 12 in the Honda service manual)
The valve cover<>shock tower<>body ground is good.
|
| Tegger | 10 Feb 2008 10:44 |
> : > Anyone ever repair a funky ECM by opening it up and cleaning up > : > any bad solder joints? Will the ECM avoid sending fuel if it sees [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > few minutes and it starts working. The ECM isn't pulling the second > relay down :( Disconnect the Main Relay's plug from the Main Relay. Connect a multimeter (set to Ohms) between the plug's Terminal 8 and a body ground.
Turn the key to "II". At thre same time as you turn the key, watch the multimeter carefully. Do you get continuity for two seconds?
Have you checked the ECU ground at the thermostat housing? Have you checked the engine grounds at the transmission housing and from valve cover to shock tower?
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
|
| Howard Goldstein | 09 Feb 2008 18:36 |
: Howard Goldstein wrote: : > Anyone ever repair a funky ECM by opening it up and cleaning up any : > bad solder joints? Will the ECM avoid sending fuel if it sees : > something "wrong" at its sensors although there aren't any codes : > stored? Should I toss the ECM at this point? : > : > Long nauseating details and plea follow: : > : : -------------------- : : If you sit there with key in position II and nothing happens (no fuel : pump), smack the dash on the left side. If the fuel pump goes : GzzzzzzCLICK, the car will now start. They NEVER fail while the engine : is running because the vibration makes the bad solder connection work : enough. : Resolder or replace the relay.
Hi, we chatted about this a few months ago. Neither resolder nor replace makes no difference. Sitting there with the key on II for a few minutes and it starts working. The ECM isn't pulling the second relay down :(
|
| motsco_ | 09 Feb 2008 18:29 |
> Anyone ever repair a funky ECM by opening it up and cleaning up any > bad solder joints? Will the ECM avoid sending fuel if it sees > something "wrong" at its sensors although there aren't any codes > stored? Should I toss the ECM at this point? > > Long nauseating details and plea follow: --------------------
If you sit there with key in position II and nothing happens (no fuel pump), smack the dash on the left side. If the fuel pump goes GzzzzzzCLICK, the car will now start. They NEVER fail while the engine is running because the vibration makes the bad solder connection work enough. Resolder or replace the relay.
'Curly'
|
| Howard Goldstein | 09 Feb 2008 13:06 |
Anyone ever repair a funky ECM by opening it up and cleaning up any bad solder joints? Will the ECM avoid sending fuel if it sees something "wrong" at its sensors although there aren't any codes stored? Should I toss the ECM at this point?
Long nauseating details and plea follow:
Recap: 94 Accord with the classic main relay (PGM-FI) symptoms (no fuel pump sound for 2 seconds as required when starting, check engine light on, can't start) with a twist: It only fails in a cold car when ambient is around above about 70F/27C, *and* leaving the key in the II (IGN) position for anywhere from 1 to 4 minutes has always allowed the second relay and then the fuel pump to kick in, CIL goes off and we're off. Never a problem while driving, and if the engine is warm it's never a problem starting. It also isn't a problem when the entire car has cooled to the low 60s/low 20s F/C or below. Cranking it doesn't help.
What I've done: I've verified there's no 12v back at the fuel pump when this happens but for good reasonI've measured battery voltage at the relay pins 6 (good) and 1 (bad) and back at the ECM A25&B1 and A7 (these are the connections to the relay) where it's good and bad (both at Vbatt). I've jumpered the service connector and the CIL stays on all the time. I've got good grounds at the ECM A connector and the PGM-FI.
What seems to be busted: WTF is up with my ECM? The skiz show the fuel pump relay in the PGM-FI won't close unless the ECM pulls down its A7 (which is PGM-FI pin 1). It doesn't pull it down, not unless the car is left in II/IGN for a couple of minutes under the conditions above.
Some specific questions:
- What else am I missing?
- Does the ECM look for other things, a sensor in a sane range or something other than battery voltage coming off of PGM-FI 6, before it'll turn on the fuel pump for the 2 seconds?
- Is it worth cracking open the ECM to reheat any obviously flakey solder joints? Can the ECM be cracked open easily?
- Anyone have a compatible ECM they'd loan me to do a swap check if I've ruled out everything else?
|
Quick links:
|
|
|